Personal tools
You are here: Home Blogs Two Intra-Ecumenical Proposals
Categories
Sermons  August 21, 2007
Editorials  August 21, 2007
Book Reviews  August 21, 2007
Blogs  August 21, 2007
Extras  August 21, 2007
Hymns  August 15, 2007
Columnists
Beth Schlegel  August 27, 2007
Clint Schnekloth  August 27, 2007
Dave Poedel  August 27, 2007
John Hannah  August 21, 2007
Mary Todd  January 23, 2008
 
Document Actions

Two Intra-Ecumenical Proposals

by Sarah Wilson September 21, 2008

The ecumenism of the past century has enabled a level of respectful, compassionate dialogue that is without precedent in the history of the church. Who would have thought five hundred years ago that Lutherans and Catholics could sit down to discuss justification without an army in sight? Or Lutherans and Mennonites could talk about public office without the former dragging out burlap bags in case a few strategic drownings of the latter were in order?...

The ecumenism of the past century has enabled a level of respectful, compassionate dialogue that is without precedent in the history of the church. Who would have thought five hundred years ago that Lutherans and Catholics could sit down to discuss justification without an army in sight? Or Lutherans and Mennonites could talk about public office without the former dragging out burlap bags in case a few strategic drownings of the latter were in order?

The funny thing is, this ecumenical habit has not been internalized. There is a nasty war—or at least series of battles—being fought out within both the ELCA and the LCMS. We despise each other because we expect the other to mirror our own ourselves back again: we’re all Lutherans here, aren’t we? So what’s the problem with you? We generally resort to calling the other’s Lutheranism into question altogether.

What we actually need is internal ecumenical dialogue. Let’s admit the rift before we have to formalize it. Let’s not make schism the actual condition of our ecumenical rapprochement! I can’t speak for Missouri, but the ELCA could stand to begin by having dialogues on the matter of sexuality; pretending that we have a task force purportedly representing us all doesn’t work. That is the most urgent item, but there are probably others: those more passionate about church politics than I could suggest them.

And then let us go to the next level: let us establish an ecumenical dialogue between the ELCA and the LCMS. Our laity talk together, work together, marry each other, love each other: why should we clergy and teachers not follow their lead and start talking too? We all know that anything resembling “union” is light years away, so there is no need for alarm on that score. But Jesus said his followers would be known by their love for each other. Let’s prove to each other that we are all followers of Jesus by outdoing each other in love instead of by the noisiness of our claims to be the true Lutherans.

I’m serious. Anyone interested? Let me know!

Now in Print

Fall 2008


Fall 2008

In this issue:

Missionary Miseries,
by One Who Had Them

Samson and Christ,
Type and Antitype

What Has Aldersgate
To Do with Wittenberg?

"Death Insurance"

Grace in the Abstract

Helmuth Rilling,
in His Own Words

...and much, much more!

Subscribe online!

Submissions
We always welcome thoughtful articles, letters to the editor, hymns, and artwork.

Submission guidelines
 

Powered by Plone CMS, the Open Source Content Management System

This site conforms to the following standards: